Navigation

Where It Started

Serving Sweet Dreams: Cookie Catering for NY Weddings in Three Unique Styles

In the world of wedding dessert tables, every couple has a unique vision for their special day, and it’s our job as cookie caterers to sweeten up their dreams. Before we relocated to Orlando and began serving the Central Florida wedding scene, we had the honor of being a part of countless New York weddings where we noticed a fascinating trend: our brides almost always fell into one of three distinct categories, each with her own flavor and style. (And by the way, as we’ve settled into the Central Florida scene, we’ve noticed that trend continues here!). But for now, let’s explore these categories: the “Park Avenue Princess,” the “Hudson River Romantic,” and the “Eclectic Downtown Diva.”

Park Avenue Princess: Opulence Reigns Supreme

For the “Park Avenue Princess” Bride and her Groom, their wedding day is nothing short of a fairy tale. They envision a celebration dripping with opulence and elegance, set against the backdrop of New York’s most luxurious venues. When it comes to dessert tables and thank you favors, only the finest gourmet cookies will do. The focus is on Luxe Flavors. These brides opt for cookies that exude sophistication. Think Brown Butter Brülée, Caramel Fleur de Sel, Lavender White Chocolate. Elegant presentation is also a must, with meticulously arranged cookies on gilded platters of silver and gold. 

Hudson River Romantic: Embracing Nature’s Beauty

The “Hudson River Romantic” Bride and her Groom seek the serenity of nature, often choosing vineyards, gardens, barns or similar rustic venues nestled amidst the mountain backdrops of the Hudson River Valley. Their love story blooms like the flowers in the countryside, and their cookies reflect this charm. The focus here is on natural flavors. These couples pile their dessert tables high with cookies infused with local ingredients like honey, apples and maple syrup. They want their guests to taste the essence of the rustic Hudson River Valley. Rustic Chic is the mantra. Cookies are presented on wooden boards or nestled in baskets adorned with wildflowers. It’s all about embracing the rustic beauty of the region.

Eclectic Downtown Diva: Modern, Edgy, and Unconventional

The “Eclectic Downtown Diva” Bride and her Groom crave an edgy, modern celebration that breaks away from tradition. Their wedding is a stylish and avant-garde affair set against the backdrop of the city that never sleeps. For them, the cookies must be as unique as their love story. For this hip couple, it’s all about bold flavors (think espresso infused dark chocolate) and unexpected twists (buttered popcorn or inside-out chocolate chips, anyone?). The presentation is bold and modern, and often interlaced with a touch of nostalgia. 

Crafting Cookie Dreams for Every Couple

As cookie caterers in the vibrant tapestry of New York weddings, we learned that each love story is as unique as the city itself. Whether it’s the opulence of the “Park Avenue Princess,” the natural charm of the “Hudson River Romantic,” or the bold flair of the “Eclectic Downtown Diva,” our cookies perfectly captured the essence of these extraordinary moments.

Our greatest joy is in crafting cookies that mirror the personalities and dreams of the couples we serve, adding a touch of sweetness to their love stories. So, no matter which category you fall into or if you’re a blend of them all, we’re here to ensure that your wedding day is a delicious reflection of your unique love story. After all, in the world of Wedding Dessert Tables and Thank You Favors, there’s a cookie flavor and style to sweeten every dream. Email us at [email protected] or call us toll free at (866) 7 COOKIE to find out how we can sweeten YOUR dream wedding whatever your bridal style!

The Cookie Jar Orlando